Workshop on Rural Women and Environment
Women and Environment (WEN) Task force (TF), APWLD
Asian Rural Women’s Conference, 6 March 2008
Workshop report
Rationale:
Asia, having by far the largest number of the World’s population, also has the largest number of rural people who are living in, economically dependant on, and culturally and socially integrated into, what can broadly be described as rural areas and communities. The main basis for the life and livelihoods of these rural communities have long been the natural resources that exist in their habitat and through adjusting and building upon these resources. It can also be stated without doubt that the close and symbiotic relationship between people and nature and the responsibility to maintain the harmony and balance between the use and extraction of available natural resources and ensuring its continued sustenance lies largely as the domain and prerogative of women.
However, with the hegemony of a globalised world, with its aggressive ideology of an economic fundamentalist approach to a market led, profit oriented, masculine ethos of corporate backed modes of production, in which exploitation and rapid destruction of natural resources occurs. Justifying this as ‘development’, ‘modernisation’, and ‘progress’ it is forced upon our peoples, with the obvious conflicts that ensues between women in traditional communities and this exploitative economic system. This then forms the base around which the workshop will be structured.
Objectives:
Experiences of women from different parts of Asia, to assess and take stock of the extent of the impacts of so called development interventions on the environment and on rural and marginalised women’s lives is one of the key objectives for this workshop. This pragmatic assessment is needed to be able to understand the extent to which our environment has been impacted, negatively or otherwise. The other objective will be to learn how women from different situations cope, adjust or resist these interventions.
Expected outputs:
- Sharing experiences and learning from each other
- Building linkages
- Developing information sharing mechanisms
- Gaining a clearer understanding of impacts and linkages between market-led economics, the environment and people’s livelihoods.
Summary of the discussion at the workshop:
Around 20-25 participants from Malaysia, India, Indonesia, Thailand, Cambodia, Bangladesh shared their experiences of the negative impact of “development projects” pursued by the government and TNCs on environment in each country and local areas. Participants also shared that the aspect of human rights violations in such environmental issues has not been recognized and addressed. The workshop was facilitated by Khushi Kabir from Nijera Kori, Bangladesh, also a member of WEN TF - APWLD.
India: 70 % of Indian population lives in rural area. The rich natural resources in rural area have been exploited by TNCs and Indian government. Extraction of gas and oil has been affecting the rural communities in close proximity to the extraction sites. Research on mining exposed the negative impact of the extraction on women’s health. Land grabbing by TNCs has led to child labor, forced displacement, loss of jobs and livelihood and sexual harassment of women working in the mines.
The irresponsible acts of TNCs and Indian government on pesticide use and disposal are rampant.
One cashew plantation has been using pesticides which have been banned by the government. There has been no actions taken by the company and the government for the breach of the regulation yet and the company continues using it to meet the demand of the market. A Coca Cola plant just moved to another place in Tamil Nadu when local people protested the contamination of water and land and health problems caused by the pesticides the plant used. The government and companies always refuse to listen to the people who have been shouldering the direct costs of the profit of TNCs.
The development projects are also destroying traditional knowledge and skills, which results in loss of jobs and migration of people from rural communities. A stone crushing company replaced traditional way of stone crushing, and as a result, people working in stone crushing in the community lost their jobs and had to move to other places to search for alternative livelihood.
Indonesia is rich with natural resources. There are oil, gas, ore, cement, gold, silver, stone etc. The rich natural resources have been exploited by TNCs and Indonesian government. Research on mining type C in Lolioge sub district Middle Sulawesi Indonesia exposed the negative impact on women. Women’s livelihoods in the mining area were planting vegetable and fruit and crushing stones. The stone companies have been grabbing communal and individual land. As a result, people especially women lost their jobs and had to search for alternative livelihood. In 2007, the Investment Law was enacted, which welcomes foreign investors with tax incentives, visa arrangements and land leasehold maximum for 95 years.
Thailand: Industrialisation projects enforced by the government have been deteriorating the environmental condition and eroding the self-sufficient economy in the community. An example is the shrimp culture industry run by TNCs, which is adversely affecting coastal environment and the local livelihood. The government turns around and blames indigenous peoples for their cutting trees as a cause of environmental degradation and has prevented them from accessing to their land. Women leaders are taking an active role in protesting environmental issues.
Malaysia: The heavy use of pesticides in plantations is damaging the health of agricultural workers, the majority of whom are women migrant workers. Plantations mostly misuse and dispose chemicals irresponsibly and do not provide their workers with protection from those harmful chemicals. Above all, plantations for biofuel such as palm oil are casing huge negative impact on people and natural environment. Forests and wetlands are being replaced by those plantations which require a lot of water and pesticides, causing contamination of drinking water, ecosystem deterioration and displacement of the communities. The policy to regulate the operation of those plantations does not address the negative impact on people. Indigenous peoples in the affected areas are not yet organised well to protest.
Bangladesh shares almost all issues other participants raised: Indigenous people in Bangladesh are being blamed for deforestation instead of companies and TNCs which should be accountable for it. Moreover, agribusiness including agrichemical industry intervening in the local agriculture and economic system led deepening indebtedness among farmers. Rural women are more vulnerable in this aggressive corporate-led globalisation adding on the traditional culture oppressive to women in unequal power relations.
Cambodia: The government has got more loans since Cambodia entered into the WTO in 2004. Policy on water, forestry and development are designed to protect the profit of corporations rather than people in Cambodia. Petroleum mining companies from Australia and the US have been operating in rural area. People particularly living in rural area have been experiencing tremendous changes in their lives and livelihood, some of whom have been displaced by the corporate projects such as mining and construction of dams. Women are more vulnerable losing their livelihood in the community and migrating to cities and other countries seeking for job opportunities which are very limited for them. To obtain accurate data by conducting researches is essential to raise awareness among civil society, organise women and demand government accountability.
Sharing those experiences, participants came up with the following strategies and recommendations:
- Obtain accurate evidence and information through case studies and researches to prove that globalisation affects rural communities and increases the vulnerability of rural women
- Map out organisations working on environmental issues at local, national, regional and international levels.
- Raise awareness on the human rights issues in general and women’s human rights in particular in environmental issues among general public, local communities and NGOs
- Hold the governments and institutions accountable for various human rights violations in relation to environmental issues.
- Empower and support organisations which support national and rural communities
- Increase women’s voices to be heard
- Organise women in unity and solidarity to tackle the violations of their human rights and difficult situations in relation to the environmental issues in the context of globalisation.
|